Five Overrated NFL Free Agents of 2025

NFL free agency is a critical period for teams looking to bolster their rosters, but it's also a time when costly mistakes can be made. Here, we delve into five players who might be overvalued in the 2025 free agency market.

1. Sam Darnold, QB

2024 Team: Minnesota Vikings

Sam Darnold had a career season with the Vikings, but his performance metrics tell a different story. Despite a strong supporting cast, Darnold ranked only 14th in QBR (60.4) during the regular season. His playoff performance further exposed his limitations. Teams should be cautious about committing significant resources to a quarterback who may not deliver consistent results.

2. Amari Cooper, WR

2024 Team: Buffalo Bills

Amari Cooper's production has significantly declined, managing only 1.6 yards per route run in 2024. Despite playing with a top-tier quarterback like Josh Allen, Cooper's impact was minimal. Advanced metrics indicate a steady decline in his performance, making him a risky investment for teams looking for a reliable wide receiver.

3. Tershawn Wharton, DT

2024 Team: Kansas City Chiefs

Wharton's sack totals might be misleading. His 7% pass rush win rate doesn't match his sack production, and playing alongside Chris Jones likely inflated his numbers. Teams should be wary of overpaying for a player whose success might be situation-dependent.

4. Najee Harris, RB

2024 Team: Pittsburgh Steelers

Najee Harris has been consistent but not exceptional. Averaging 3.9 yards per carry over his career, Harris hasn't lived up to the hype of being a first-round pick. Teams should consider whether his availability outweighs his lack of standout performance.

5. Paulson Adebo, CB

2024 Team: New Orleans Saints

Cornerback performance is notoriously difficult to predict, and Adebo's high target rate and yards per coverage snap metrics are concerning. While he has had some impressive interceptions, his overall performance doesn't justify a high-value contract.

As NFL teams navigate the 2025 free agency period, it’s essential to look beyond the surface stats and consider the long-term implications of each signing. Overpaying for overrated players can have lasting negative effects on team performance and financial flexibility.