College Football Coaches' First-Year Reviews: Hits, Misses, and What's Next

A look at the first-year performances of college football coaches in 2024, including their hires, records, and grades.

The 2024 college football season saw a number of new coaches take the reins at various programs. Some made an immediate impact, while others struggled to find their footing. Here's a look at how the first-year coaches fared and what's next for them.

UCLA Bruins

DeShaun Foster took over as head coach at UCLA and led the Bruins to a 5-7 record. Foster was a late-cycle promotion, but he took over the role amid some skepticism about his readiness. He drew a better mark from me than other hiring evaluators, but the concern increased after his Big Ten media day freeze-up, and after the team started 1-5 while playing a very tough schedule. But Foster never lost the locker room and the Bruins put together a nice midseason win streak against Rutgers, Nebraska, and Iowa, claiming the first two on the road. Other than the Big Ten opener against Indiana, UCLA competed, even in its losses, and saw linebacker Carson Schwesinger emerge into a national star. Foster's offseason staff overhaul suggests he will have more of an imprint on the program this coming season. He also should have a greater comfort level overall.

Boston College Eagles

Bill O'Brien was hired as the head coach at Boston College and led the Eagles to a 7-6 record. O'Brien understands how to run a team, which came across in his first season at Boston College, despite some expected inconsistency in performance. He guided the Eagles to a 4-1 start that included wins against Florida State and Michigan State, with the lone blemish being a six-point loss at Missouri. Boston College then endured a three-game losing streak that culminated with a quarterback change from Thomas Castellanos to Grayson James. O'Brien made a tough call there but seemingly the right one, as James helped BC to wins over Syracuse, North Carolina, and Pitt. Despite a very late coaching change, the Eagles made their second straight bowl appearance in O'Brien's first season.

Michigan Wolverines

Sherrone Moore was hired as the head coach at Michigan and led the Wolverines to an 8-5 record. Michigan wasn't truly built to return to the College Football Playoff after winning the national title in 2023, especially without adding a transfer quarterback to replace J.J. McCarthy. But the team's offensive regression -- Michigan slipped to 130th nationally in passing, ahead of only the three service academies -- and some of Moore's in-game decisions stirred doubt about the first-year coach. Michigan split its first 10 games and went 0-3 on the road. Moore delivered down the stretch, though, as Michigan clobbered Northwestern and then stunned Ohio State in Columbus as a three-touchdown underdog. The Wolverines beat the Buckeyes for the fourth straight year and second under Moore, who served as acting head coach for the 2023 victory. Moore then guided a vastly undermanned Wolverines team over Alabama in the ReliaQuest Bowl, regaining the momentum lost during the first two-plus months of the season.

What to Read Next

Pudge the Cat: The Unlikely Mascot Leading Bowling Green to Football Glory
NCAAF

Pudge the Cat: The Unlikely Mascot Leading Bowling Green to Football Glory

Discover how Pudge the Cat has become the heart and soul of Bowling Green's football team, boosting morale and leading them to an impressive season start.

NCAAF Showdown: Texas Tech vs Utah and Other Top 25 Matchups This Week
NCAAF

NCAAF Showdown: Texas Tech vs Utah and Other Top 25 Matchups This Week

Explore the latest NCAAF betting lines and FPI predictions for Texas Tech vs Utah, Auburn vs Oklahoma, and other top 25 matchups this week.

Week 3 NCAAF Highlights: Texas A&M's Rise, UCLA's Struggles, and Key Performances
NCAAF

Week 3 NCAAF Highlights: Texas A&M's Rise, UCLA's Struggles, and Key Performances

Explore the biggest stories from Week 3 of NCAAF, including Texas A&M's impressive start, UCLA's challenges, and standout player performances.

NCAAF Week 3 Power Rankings: Breakout Stars and Game-Changing Performances
NCAAF

NCAAF Week 3 Power Rankings: Breakout Stars and Game-Changing Performances

Discover the standout players and teams from NCAAF Week 3, as we delve into the power rankings and highlight the breakout stars shaping the 2025 season.

College Football Playoff and Bowl Projections: Analyzing the Fallout from a Wild Weekend
NCAAF

College Football Playoff and Bowl Projections: Analyzing the Fallout from a Wild Weekend

Explore the latest College Football Playoff and bowl projections after a weekend of upsets and standout performances.

NCAAF Week 2 Power Rankings: Key Takeaways, Surprises, and Areas for Improvement
NCAAF

NCAAF Week 2 Power Rankings: Key Takeaways, Surprises, and Areas for Improvement

Dive into the key takeaways, surprises, and areas for improvement from Week 2 of the NCAAF season. Explore how the Top 25 teams performed and what lies ahead.

Unveiling the 2025 NCAAF Season: SEC QBs, Big 12 Dominance, and Oregon's Rise
NCAAF

Unveiling the 2025 NCAAF Season: SEC QBs, Big 12 Dominance, and Oregon's Rise

Explore the thrilling start to the 2025 NCAAF season, featuring SEC quarterback showdowns, Big 12's fierce competition, and Oregon's dominant rise.

Florida State's Dominance Sets the Stage for a Thrilling Week 6 Showdown Against Miami
NCAAF

Florida State's Dominance Sets the Stage for a Thrilling Week 6 Showdown Against Miami

Florida State's impressive early-season performances have set the stage for a pivotal Week 6 matchup against Miami, highlighting their potential as a top contender in college football.

NCAAF Power 4 Struggles: Alabama's Rolled Tide and Other Week 1 Disappointments
NCAAF

NCAAF Power 4 Struggles: Alabama's Rolled Tide and Other Week 1 Disappointments

Explore the Week 1 struggles of NCAAF's Power 4 teams, including Alabama's surprising loss and other notable disappointments in the season opener.

NCAAF Week 1 Recap: Top 25 Teams' Performances and What's Next
NCAAF

NCAAF Week 1 Recap: Top 25 Teams' Performances and What's Next

A comprehensive recap of NCAAF Week 1, highlighting the top 25 teams' performances, key stats, and upcoming matchups.

Belichick's UNC Debut Ends in Historic Defeat: TCU's Dominance in Week 1 NCAAF Showdown
NCAAF

Belichick's UNC Debut Ends in Historic Defeat: TCU's Dominance in Week 1 NCAAF Showdown

Bill Belichick's first game as UNC head coach ended in a record-breaking 48-14 loss to TCU, marking the most points ever allowed by a Belichick-led team.

NCAAF Power Rankings 2025: Week 1 Insights and Top 25 Teams Analysis
NCAAF

NCAAF Power Rankings 2025: Week 1 Insights and Top 25 Teams Analysis

Explore the latest NCAAF Power Rankings after Week 1, featuring in-depth analysis of each top 25 team's performance and key takeaways.

NCAAF Week 1 Insights: Arch Manning's Debut Struggles and Utah's Dominant Start
NCAAF

NCAAF Week 1 Insights: Arch Manning's Debut Struggles and Utah's Dominant Start

Explore key takeaways from NCAAF Week 1, including Arch Manning's challenging debut and Utah's impressive performance in the Big 12.

CFP Top 12 Projections: Week 1 Shakeup and Playoff Implications
NCAAF

CFP Top 12 Projections: Week 1 Shakeup and Playoff Implications

Analyzing the potential CFP top 12 after Week 1, with insights into key matchups, team performances, and playoff implications.

Bill Belichick's Transformative Impact on North Carolina Football: A New Era Begins
NCAAF

Bill Belichick's Transformative Impact on North Carolina Football: A New Era Begins

Explore how Bill Belichick is reshaping North Carolina football, from recruiting strategies to his NFL-inspired approach, as the Tar Heels aim for national prominence.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.