MLB's Worst Moves Since 2020: The 30 Biggest Blunders

A look at the 30 worst moves by MLB teams since 2020, ranked from least to most damaging.

This is no secret: Front offices are smarter than ever and, believe it or not, make fewer mistakes than ever. Fewer big mistakes, at least. Consider some of the players traded as prospects last decade (from 2010-19): Yordan Alvarez, Zack Wheeler, Max Fried, Trea Turner, Luis Castillo, Sandy Alcantara, Zac Gallen, Dansby Swanson, Fernando Tatis Jr., Dylan Cease, Anthony Rizzo, Patrick Corbin, Lucas Giolito, Willy Adames, Jesus Luzardo, Gleyber Torres.That's six of the top 12 pitchers this decade via WAR and five of the top 30 position players. Some of the deals worked out for the teams trading away the prospect: The Cubs won a World Series with Aroldis Chapman (traded for Torres) and the Nationals won a World Series with Adam Eaton (traded for Giolito) -- but most did not.We're halfway through the 2020s and we haven't seen nearly as many of those kinds of trades (so far, anyway). Top prospects are the gold currency of MLB, to be parted with only in acts of desperation. But mistakes have still been made: bad trades, bad signings, bad decisions in the playoffs. Stealing an idea from ESPN NFL writer Bill Barnwell, we're going to dig up the worst decision each team has made through these past five years, evaluating the outcome and not the process.We'll start with the least damaging of the moves and end with the biggest mistake so far of the 2020s.Jump to a team:American LeagueATH | BAL | BOS | CHW | CLEDET | HOU | KC | LAA | MINNYY | | SEA | TB | TEX | TORNational LeagueARI | ATL | CHC | CIN | COL LAD | MIA | MIL | NYM | PHIPIT | SD | SF | STL | WSH

What to Read Next

2025 MLB Season: Record-Breaking Performances and Key Statistics
MLB

2025 MLB Season: Record-Breaking Performances and Key Statistics

Explore the defining stats and record-breaking performances of the 2025 MLB season, featuring Aaron Judge, Paul Skenes, Shohei Ohtani, and Cal Raleigh.

Fantasy Baseball 2026: Rising Stars and Declining Veterans - Who to Watch?
MLB

Fantasy Baseball 2026: Rising Stars and Declining Veterans - Who to Watch?

Explore the future of Fantasy Baseball with insights on rising stars like Riley Greene and Oneil Cruz, and declining veterans such as Rafael Devers and Juan Soto.

Red Sox Ownership Under Fire: The Fallout from the Rafael Devers Trade
MLB

Red Sox Ownership Under Fire: The Fallout from the Rafael Devers Trade

The Boston Red Sox face backlash from fans after trading Rafael Devers, raising questions about the team's leadership and future direction.

Future Stars in MLB: Analyzing the Impact of Rafael Devers Trade on Rising Prospects
MLB

Future Stars in MLB: Analyzing the Impact of Rafael Devers Trade on Rising Prospects

Explore how the Rafael Devers trade reshapes the future of MLB prospects, focusing on key players like James Tibbs III and Bryce Eldridge.

Tensions Rise as Dodgers' Andy Pages Claims Intentional HBP by Padres' Dylan Cease
MLB

Tensions Rise as Dodgers' Andy Pages Claims Intentional HBP by Padres' Dylan Cease

Andy Pages of the Dodgers accuses Padres' Dylan Cease of intentionally hitting him with a pitch, reigniting the fierce rivalry between the two teams.

Shohei Ohtani's Return to the Mound Sparks Surge in Dodgers-Padres Ticket Prices
MLB

Shohei Ohtani's Return to the Mound Sparks Surge in Dodgers-Padres Ticket Prices

Shohei Ohtani's first pitching appearance since 2023 has caused a significant surge in ticket prices for the Dodgers-Padres game.

Shohei Ohtani's Pitching Comeback: A Historic Night at Dodger Stadium
MLB

Shohei Ohtani's Pitching Comeback: A Historic Night at Dodger Stadium

Shohei Ohtani makes a triumphant return to the mound, showcasing his dual-threat capabilities in a memorable game at Dodger Stadium.

MLB Tuesday Guide: Expert Fantasy Baseball Lineup Tips & Betting Insights
MLB

MLB Tuesday Guide: Expert Fantasy Baseball Lineup Tips & Betting Insights

Get expert advice on setting your fantasy baseball lineups and placing smart MLB bets for Tuesday's games. Includes pitching and hitting insights, betting tips, and player matchups.

MLB Fantasy Baseball: Top Waiver Wire Picks to Boost Your Rotation in Week 13
MLB

MLB Fantasy Baseball: Top Waiver Wire Picks to Boost Your Rotation in Week 13

Discover the top waiver wire picks for MLB fantasy baseball in Week 13, including high-strikeout pitchers and emerging outfielders to strengthen your roster.

Rafael Devers Shocks MLB: Giants Land Star Slugger in Blockbuster Trade
MLB

Rafael Devers Shocks MLB: Giants Land Star Slugger in Blockbuster Trade

The Giants acquire Rafael Devers from the Red Sox in a stunning mid-season trade, reshaping the NL West race and sparking debates across the baseball world.

Blockbuster Trade: Giants Acquire Rafael Devers from Red Sox in Shocking MLB Move
MLB

Blockbuster Trade: Giants Acquire Rafael Devers from Red Sox in Shocking MLB Move

The San Francisco Giants stunned the MLB world by acquiring All-Star Rafael Devers from the Boston Red Sox in a blockbuster trade. Learn how this move impacts both teams.

MLB Trade Deadline 2025: Executives Under Pressure to Shape Team Futures
MLB

MLB Trade Deadline 2025: Executives Under Pressure to Shape Team Futures

As the 2025 MLB trade deadline approaches, key executives face critical decisions that could define their teams' futures. Explore the pressures and potential moves.

Rafael Devers Trade to Giants: Fantasy Baseball Impact and Future Prospects
MLB

Rafael Devers Trade to Giants: Fantasy Baseball Impact and Future Prospects

Explore how Rafael Devers' trade to the Giants impacts his fantasy baseball potential and what it means for the future of both teams.

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Monday: Expert Tips and Lineup Strategies
MLB

Ultimate MLB Fantasy Baseball and Betting Guide for Monday: Expert Tips and Lineup Strategies

Get expert advice on setting your MLB fantasy baseball lineups and placing bets for Monday's games. Discover top pitchers, hitters, and betting insights.

Austin Gomber Returns to Rockies' Rotation: Key Insights and Impact on Braves Game
MLB

Austin Gomber Returns to Rockies' Rotation: Key Insights and Impact on Braves Game

Austin Gomber is back in the Rockies' lineup after recovering from a shoulder injury, ready to face the Braves in a crucial Sunday game.

Load More

We use essential cookies to make our site work. With your consent, we may also use non-essential cookies to improve user experience and analyze website traffic. By clicking "Accept," you agree to our website's cookie use as described in our Cookie Policy.