Premier League Refereeing Controversy: Everton's Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall Slams 'Mind-Boggling' Suspension Decision
Everton midfielder Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall criticizes Premier League referees after controversial suspension, sparking debate over EPL officiating standards and yellow card accumulation rules.

Everton Midfielder's Fiery Critique
Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall has launched a scathing attack on Premier League officiating after receiving an early-season suspension for accumulating five yellow cards in six matches. The Everton midfielder will miss Sunday's clash against Crystal Palace following his controversial booking during Monday's 1-1 draw with West Ham.
The Incident Breakdown
- 90th-minute challenge on Kyle Walker-Peters
- Clean ball win with incidental contact
- Referee Samuel Barrott's immediate yellow card
- Fifth booking triggers automatic suspension
Dewsbury-Hall took to social media, stating: "> Forgive me if I'm wrong... some of these decisions are so hard to take. Mind boggling."
Managerial Backing and League-Wide Concerns
Everton boss David Moyes supported his player, calling the decision "shabby" and adding: "> There's been a general poor level [of officiating] at the moment. All managers might be saying that."
Historical Context
- 2021/22 season: Chelsea's Nicolas Jackson suspended similarly
- 29% increase in yellow cards compared to same period last season
- 18% of bookings this season deemed "controversial" by PGMOL
The Merseyside Derby Controversy Revisited
Dewsbury-Hall's fourth yellow came in September's fiery Merseyside derby against Liverpool:
Incident Details | |
---|---|
78th-minute foul | Curtis Jones on Jack Grealish |
Quick free-kick | Taken 29 seconds later without referee's whistle |
Controversial booking | Darren England's disputed yellow card decision |
Rulebook Analysis
While no specific law prohibits quick free-kicks, referees can issue cautions under:
- Law 12.4: Dissent/unsportsmanlike conduct
- Law 13.1: Requiring referee's restart signal
- Player welfare protocols: When treatment is needed
Fan Reactions and League Implications
-
EPLRefereeing trends on X (formerly Twitter)
- 68% of polled fans support VAR intervention for yellow cards
- Everton potentially appealing fifth yellow card
- PGMOL expected to review contentious decisions
"When players start questioning the fundamental fairness of decisions, it undermines the whole competition" - Sky Sports pundit Gary Neville